Not necessarily for You
My job (no matter which one you refer to), entails a great deal of advice giving. Now on one hand its as easy as telling customers how to make their lives easier by doing something simple and scripted like mowing the lawn, trimming their trees and cleaning up counter tops so food doesn't attract pests. Simple enough solutions for whom the consequences become immediately apparent: You don't follow the advice given, the situation will not change for the better or worse. Sure, there are some exceptions to the precision of the advice itself or if its a unique situation I may flat out just be wrong about what I initially said. However, it ultimately comes around to being a part of a problem that has a predocumented and fairly limited solution.Now, my other job....
For those of you who don't know me, I'm a soldier in the Army National Guard. (probably putting too much info out there but, please don't be my enemy and use it against me? Kay? =] ) I've had to have conversations a limited percentage of my country's population has ever had to have themselves. There's an inherent responsibility with a leadership position to have to attempt to wear the boots of a parent, guardian, older sibling or some sort of counselor regardless of your personal age or experience. So though I may carry around a pretty robust and prime 27 year old frame, I and many like me in my postion feel to some extent a couple hundred thousand years old at times. As if the weight of not only your intelligence and understanding but all that you must attempt to see and experience on purpose can come crashing down on you at any given moment. Where your words are the guiding light for somone younger and feeling less able than you are needed to pull themselves from the shadows of dispair.
So here's my advice:
Though answering questions is the better part of being a school teacher to help a student get a better grade, more often than not I find it necessary to provide guiding semi-cryptic responses for a question you know the anwer to rather than provide a blatant doubtless solution in the form of a simple sentence or two. People...people have a capacity to learn on their own byt discovering strength in remaining humble. To be able, in all situations, to step back and remain objective with their reasoning and open to new thoughts or ideas empowers them to have a much more enduring and potent solution to whatever their problem may be.
Who am I to say what is right or wrong though? Shouldn't someone's life be their own soveriegn existance no matter the issue? If they want a divorce or to kill themselves; to throw away all of their money and position in life; to simply be young and dumb and actively try to fall for a stripper or do recreational drugs? Am I wrong to have intervened when asked? Or even when I wasn't asked? I'm told it's my responsibility at times to do so. Other times I simply feel obligated to.
Whatever the cause or effect, my reasoning has never changed and I believe it applies to all:
The right course of action is the one in service of another. Forget the "best interest" argument we associate with our emotional knee-jerk reaction to put our two cents in entitlement thought process. When you sacrifice your own belief for whats in the best interest of another for the servitude of their developement, that minute change in semantics is enough to destinguish your perspective into becoming more objective, unbiased. We don't live in a fair world; we do not have a fair existence; we are slowly but acceleratively destroying ourselves and through all of this, we can still see the need to fight our way through to a better future. That's how I have to apply my thought process to the advice I give because I know nothing else. I haven't seen a properly passive solution, I haven't seen any inaction be the better course to embark save for when its the better part of valor. (Let me know if you can't understand that sentence but I kinda like it! lol)
Long and short of it is, life for me has been a sequence of battles. Though varied in type and scope, the required mechanics and fundamental thought process (Semper "Gumby") applies to all situations. So if you find yourself struggling for the words to say in a situation that you've never been in for a person you're not actually related to rememeber:
"Breathe, relax, aim, and squeeze." -US Army acronym (BRAS) for fundamentals of marksmanshipApply and serve to your solution.
-G